How the gig economy could create hidden tax issues for contractors and employers
Workers and employers are benefiting from the burgeoning gig economy in which people work part-time or on a project basis, often for a stable of employers.
However, this is creating some uncertainty around whether people are independent contractors or employees, or a hybrid of both.
Misinterpreting the arrangements can lead to inadvertent breaches of various legislation, as was demonstrated in the Fair Work Commission’s decision in Joshua Klooger v Foodora Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FWC 6836.
While Mr Klooger had entered into an independent contractor agreement with Foodora that stipulated he was a contractor and not an employee, the Fair Work Commission found that he was, in fact, an employee based on the “totality of the relationship”. This meant Mr Klooger had been unfairly dismissed and was entitled to compensation.
Furthermore, the tax authorities swooped after the decision, finding that payroll tax obligations existed, as well as other employment tax obligations such as pay-as-you-go withholding (PAYGW), superannuation and personal services income (PSI).
These decisions meant that Foodora was liable for millions of dollars of potentially unpaid withholding taxes and superannuation. Compounding the problem, the decision of the Fair Work Commission effectively changed the flow of income for both Foodora and its workers. The cumulative impact meant that the German-founded food delivery business had to leave Australia.
Instead of the independent receiving all the income and paying an amount to the digital platform provider, the result is now that the digital platform provider receives all the income and pays some of that to its employees. While this may not change the bottom line for either, the implications across a range of stakeholders including banks, government departments and auditors are significant.
Tax authorities in Australia have been grappling with this issue for many years and, to date, no attempts to solve the problem have been effective. The Foodora example illustrates the potential pitfalls for many businesses when it comes to embracing the gig economy. The line between independent contractors and employees remains murky, which could affect businesses in a range of different industries.
Contractors are not technically employees of the business, so they usually get paid by issuing the business an invoice for their services and then pay their own superannuation, tax instalments and liability insurance, as well as any other costs of doing business.
This common example of a relationship between a contractor and a business has generally been accepted by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), but the Foodora case could lead to changes. If the ATO were to take the view that these relationships were, in fact, employee relationships, then there would be a large number of contractors and businesses that would need to reconsider their tax structures and affairs.
This could mean significant out-of-pocket expenses for businesses as they would need to pay wages to their employees, pay the superannuation guarantee charge (SCG), allow for leave entitlements and ensure their insurances covered their employees.
The contractors themselves would have their tax affairs simplified but would also be unable to continue claiming certain tax deductions or splitting income through certain tax structures.
If the contractor and business elected to continue with the current independent contractor arrangement, the ATO may seek to review the arrangement with the following outcomes:
- Request the business pay an applicable outstanding SGC to the contractor’s superannuation fund. As this would be late-paid superannuation, no tax deduction would be allowed for the payment.
- Charge a 10 per cent interest rate and quarterly administration fees on the unpaid SGC amounts.
- Amend the contractor’s income tax return under the personal services income (PSI) provisions to disallow certain deductions and income splitting.
These developments mean it’s critical for any business engaging independent contractors to seek expert advice to ensure they understand the issues and take all steps to ensure their business model works. Failing to do so could be catastrophic, as was illustrated by Foodora’s forced exit from the Australian market.
Tony Ince and Kane Zaknich, RSM Australia
22 November 2019
accountantsdaily.com.au
Hot Issues
- FBT Reminder – Odometer Reading
- ATO’s debts on hold campaign prompts new IGTO guidance
- A comprehensive collection of small business benchmarks
- The 2025 Financial Year tax & super changes you need to know!
- Underperforming employees: When can you terminate?
- A comprehensive list of guides to industry specific tax deductions.
- ‘Renewed concerns’ about economy sees consumer sentiment dip: Westpac
- Oldest Buildings in the World.
- Small businesses may ‘collapse under strain of payday super’, IPA warns
- ATO’s hands tied with scrapping on-hold debts, expert says
- What Drives Your Business Growth and Profits?
- Australian Taxation Office (ATO) shifting to firmer debt collection activity
- Why employee v contractor comes down to fine print
- Sharing economy reporting regime for platform operators
- Countries producing the most solar power by gigawatt hours
- Illegal access nets $637 million
- Accessing superannuation benefits.
- Does your business have a company Power of Attorney?
- Labor tweaks stage 3 tax cuts to make room for ‘middle Australia’
- GrantConnect
- 2 in 3 SMEs benefit from instant asset write-off, survey reveals
- Updated guidance on R&D claims
- Do you know how to recover debts?
- Wheat Production by Country
- Types of small business benchmarks
- What is a Commercial Lease?
- ATO warns advisers against suspect R&D tax claims
- The year of workplace law upheaval
- Vimeo test
Article archive
- January - March 2024
- October - December 2023
- July - September 2023
- April - June 2023
- January - March 2023
- October - December 2022
- July - September 2022
- April - June 2022
- January - March 2022
- October - December 2021
- July - September 2021
- April - June 2021
- January - March 2021
- October - December 2020
- July - September 2020
- April - June 2020
- January - March 2020
- October - December 2019
- July - September 2019
- April - June 2019
- January - March 2019
- October - December 2018
- July - September 2018
- April - June 2018
- January - March 2018
- October - December 2017
- July - September 2017
- April - June 2017
- January - March 2017
- October - December 2016
- July - September 2016
- April - June 2016
- January - March 2016
- October - December 2015
- July - September 2015
- April - June 2015
- January - March 2015
- October - December 2014
What our clients say about us